The chief outcome of the work was the conclusion that. It is perhaps best known for being low in calories, typically between 30 and 50 per 8 oz. Exclusive human milk feeding for the first 6 months of life, with continued breastfeeding for 1 to 2 years of life or longer, is recognized as the normative standard for infant feeding. The fat and lactose, respectively, provide 50% and 40% of the total energy of the milk. Differences between cows and human milk jama network. There is a belief that the breast milk can increase the intelligence of the children, which cow milk does not have. Leucocytes in human milk and lymphocyte subsets in cows. Animals that grow quickly after birth have higher levels of protein and leucine in their milk. Feeding breast milk until the child is at least for six months is recommended. Although breastfeeding is highly recommended, breastfeeding may not always be possible, suitable or solely adequate. Breastfeeding is generally accepted as the optimal method of feeding infants. May 11, 2016 in cows milk, whey proteins represent only 18% of milk protein.
Many mothers do not realize there is a difference between breast milk and formula. Human breast milk contains 3 times less protein than cow s milk hernell, 2011. Human breast milk contains 3 times less protein than cows milk hernell, 2011. Pediatricians and nutritionists use charts of infant growth weight, size, head circumference and neurodevelopment criteria that reflect the food that these infants receive. Differences between human breast milk and cow milk. This contrasting result might be due to differences in milk composition between species. In addition to those nutrients breast milk also provides the infant with immune factors, growth and hormone factors, and enzymes. However, the concentration or presence of several specific components e. Feb 12, 2019 breast milk composition changes during a feed, and fat concentration increases with longer nursing sessions. The fundamental composition of breast milk includes, protein, salt, and sugar, which are all contained in a fat suspension.
However, the composition of human breast milk is dynamic and changes over time. The composition of the milk differs only slightly within animals, but it contains significant amounts of saturated fats, proteins, calcium, and vitamins especially vitamin c. Breast milk or mothers milk is milk produced by mammary glands located in the breast of a human female to feed a child. Formula can be life saving in certain situations but there is absolutely no research and common sense will tell you to support the idea that a toddler should be switched to a milk which is for a different species instead of. In cows milk, whey proteins represent only 18% of milk protein. The aim of the present study is to list the compositions of milk of different species and discuss their nutritional values. Mooove over, cows milk the rise of plantbased dairy alternatives health concerns. Sep 21, 2011 human milk is obviously thinner and sweeter than cows milk.
Jul 21, 2011 after few days, milk becomes white in colour, and it is called mature or true milk. What is the difference between human milk and cow milk. This is a pdf file of an unedited manuscript that has. The nutrient contents including the protein quality of the nondairy beverages and cows milk were compared. A baby under age 1 should not drink cow s milk, because his stomach cant digest the proteins in cow s milk well. Similarly, the fatty acid composition of cows milk is more suited to a calf than to a person. Comparison of human milk, cows milk and infant formulas for their antifungal effects against environmental fungi aim. It is not related to effects of estrogen on the baby.
The composition of the milk of various animal species differs, but in every case it has a high priority in human nutrition. In this video we look under the scope to compare the differences between breastmilk, infants formula, cows milk, and almond milk. Reduced milk volume has been reported in some but not all studies. Also, the nutrient contents differ with more proteins and minerals in cow milk however, breast milk has more lipids and lactose. However, the composition of human breast milk is dynamic and changes over time, adapting itself to the changing needs of the growing child. Nov 27, 2018 as the table shows, goat milk provides slightly less carbohydrate than regular cows milk 4. The fat content is similar or about 38 gl in human and cows milk but.
Both cow milk and goat milk tend to be more nutritious in the winter and early spring when the early milk colostrum is produced than in the summer when the milk production has run its course. Cow s milk contains 20 % protein, 51% fat, and 29% carbs, whereas human breast has 6% protein, 55% fat, and 39% carbs. Mothers own milk is the best source of nutrition for nearly all infants. Above table contains gross composition of different animals.
More than 5% of the worlds milk comes from buffaloes. Since this pattern suggested full breast feeding as the driver of excessive weight gain, we analyzed the human milk composition at the infant age of 1 year and compared the results with published. The vast majority of infants in the united states are fed human milk substitutes by 6 months of age. Studies of human milk composition also vary in their attention to storage or. Colostrum also contains important infectionfighting antibodies. However, the composition of human breast milk is dynamic and. Comparison of human milk, cows milk and infant formulas for. Milk yield, milk composition, and milk metabolomics of. Breast milk composition changes as baby grows in age. It bridges the nutritional gap between intrauterine dependence and extrauterine independence. The digestion of a1 types of casein in cow milk leads to the. A baby under age 1 should not drink cows milk, because his stomach cant digest the proteins in cows milk well. Over 95% of the world buffalo milk is produced in asia charan, 1994. In the first few days after birth, a special type of milk called colostrum is excreted which is rich in fats and protein.
Research suggests that the chemical composition of goat milk may make it easier to digest. Soy, like cow s milk, is one of the most common allergies in children. Difference between cow milk and human milk compare the. Comparison of human milk, cows milk and infant formulas. Because the amino acid profiles of casein and whey proteins are different, the overall amino acid profile of human milk varies depending on the stage of lactation. Mar 19, 2020 the negative effects of heat stress hs on the productivity of dairy animals in terms of milk yield, milk composition and milk quality are well documented 1,2. The vast majority of infants in the united states are fed humanmilk substitutes by 6 months of age. Breast milk is uniquely tailored by each mom to meet the specific needs of her baby. Cow milk is comprised mostly of long chain fatty acids while goat milk has much more medium and even short chain fatty acids. Milk composition, synthesis learn with flashcards, games, and more for free. What is the difference between store bought milk and milk. Some factor or factors in the nature of the proteins of cows and human milk may be concerned, and differences in the aminoacid composition of the proteins of the. Cows milk and cows milk formula are made for just thata baby cow it is species specific for a growing calf.
Sweetened varieties, however, can contain up to 90 calories per cup and 16 g of sugar. The nutrient contents of nondairy beverages and cows milk were also. The potential effect on the infant is a slower growth rate due to reduced milk intake. These considerations continue today as manufacturers attempt to alter infant formulas to imitate human milk in either composition or performance and to address the nutritional needs of specific infant populations e. Information about the nondairy beverages on the shelves at stores in buffalo, new york was collected. However, as you can see from the chart there are many differences between the two. After drinking milk that was specific to me as a human, i didnt recognize cows milk and i didnt like it at all. Attempts to alter the fatty acid composition of cows milk, and so increase the nutritional value of cows milk to humans, have involved experiments feeding cows fish meal and soya beans abughazaleh et al. Differences in chemical composition between cow colostrum and milk 6 bjvm, 11, no 1 lar to that of normal milk. That was the cows milk i had been drinking my whole life. An experiment comparing the taste of cows milk to human. The various constituents are given as percentages of the whole milk. When mothers take estrogen supplements, there is a very small amount of estrogen that ends up in human breast milk.
The purpose of the present study was to investigate and compare the antifungal effect of human milk with infant formula and cows milk. Since goats generally graze on fresh pasture, goat milk also offers a higher amount of omega3. Although both cow and goat milk contains casein protein, the specific composition is slightly different. Difference between breast milk and cow milk compare the. May, 2017 in this video we look under the scope to compare the differences between breastmilk, infant s formula, cow s milk, and almond milk.
Breast milk composition changes to match the age and various nutritional requirements of your child. Breast milk or mother s milk is milk produced by mammary glands located in the breast of a human female to feed a child. Breast milk is produced in the mammary glands of women. When she told me what the two types of milk were and after i recovered from my surprise i was amazed. Traditionally, infant formulas are high in casein, making them harder to digest compared to human breast milk. Mooove over, cows milk the rise of plantbased dairy. Human milk contains a high amount of antibodies, specific to the human child. The negative effects of heat stress hs on the productivity of dairy animals in terms of milk yield, milk composition and milk quality are well documented 1,2. Infant formula, baby formula or just formula american english or baby milk, infant milk or first milk british english, is a manufactured food designed and marketed for feeding to babies and infants under 12 months of age, usually prepared for bottlefeeding or cupfeeding from powder mixed with water or liquid with or without additional water. A comparison of the nutritional value of cows milk and. Breast milk contains over 200 nutritional, as well as functional, components. The same nutrients are present in the milk of all species, although in different proportions.
Human milk and evolution of infant formulas 21 it is fair to say that the major goals have been met. Cows milk, without dilutions or the present is in the alpha form in human milk. Until the early 20th century, a wet nurse was the only safe alternative to breast feeding, one reason being that each species has a unique composition of its milk. Human milk is obviously thinner and sweeter than cows milk. Colostrum also contains important infectionfighting antibodies which strengthen the immune system of the young mammal. The web pages of several manufacturers were assessed for product contents. But doctors will recommend soy formula if they believe an infant should.
Breast milk continues to provide the best nutrition after 1 year, but milk, no matter what type, no longer meets all your childs nutrition needs. Breast milk continues to provide the best nutrition after 1 year, but milk, no matter what type, no longer meets all your child s nutrition needs. The composition of human milk is the biologic norm for infant nutrition. The lysozyme activity in the colostrum of cows with high and low milk yield changes from 0. Leucine is a unique amino acid which is linked with growth. Beyond somatic growth, breast milk as a biologic fluid has a variety of other benefits, including modulation of postnatal intestinal function, immune ontogeny, and brain development. According to research, breast milk is an infants most valuable source of nutrients, minerals and disease fighting cells and antibodies, a requirement that does not have any replacement in this world.
Although 62% of us infants were breastfed as newborns in 2008, 73% of these were transitioned to infant formula between birth and age 6 months. Past literature provides only incomplete snapshots of breast milk composition. Dec 17, 2018 a baby under age 1 should not drink cow s milk, because his stomach cant digest the proteins in cow s milk well. Human breast milk is a complex matrix with a general composition of 87% water, 3. Soy, like cows milk, is one of the most common allergies in children. Cows milk composition can vary widely between different breeds and during different stages of lactation. The presence of vitamin c makes the milk to be slightly acidic. Comparison of human breast milk nutrition to goats milk. Also, the nutrient contents differ with more proteins and minerals in cow.
It is called raw milk, godnature or what ever you believe in has given mother of a mammal this power to produce life giving fluid to her off spring. Human milk is easily digested by human infants, and they cannot digest cow milk in similar efficiency. Additionally, breast milk has vitamin c which is not in cow milk. That said, cow milk is not very similar to human milk.
Breast milk and formula milk compositions cocoscience. The following chart compares the composition of formula to that of human breast milk. The bone strengthening properties of cows milk are well known but breast milk is the total nutritional package for kids under one year old. There is no ideal composition of human milk and also no easy way to control the complexity of its nutritional quality and the quantity received by breastfed infants. From the chemical laboratory of the new york state agricultural ezperi ment station, geneva.
Cow milk or soymilk are most commonly used as the base, with supplemental. Goat milk is a good source of b vitamins especially riboflavinvitamin b2 and vitamin a. Breastfeeding vs formula difference and comparison diffen. Milk yield, milk composition, and milk metabolomics of dairy. Mechanisms of synthesis of milk components are introduced. According to research, breast milk is an infant s most valuable source of nutrients, minerals and disease fighting cells and antibodies, a requirement that does not have any replacement in this world. Comparison of chemical and mineral content of milk from. The composition of human milk includes numbers for early milk and mature milk from the australian national health and medical research councils nhmrc infant feeding guidelines for health workers note.
This food source, although inferior to human milk in multiple respects, promotes more efficient growth, development, and nutrient balance than commercially available cow milk. Milk is the primary source of nutrition for newborns before they are able to eat and digest other foods. Here are the major differences between cow and human breast milk explained. Both are about 88% water, but human milk has 7% carbohydrate, 1. Developmental status of 1yearold infants fed breast milk. Cows milk contains 20 % protein, 51% fat, and 29% carbs, whereas human breast has 6% protein, 55% fat, and 39% carbs. It is estimated that about 20 percent of formulafed infants are fed soy proteinbased formula during their first year of life.
Breast milk composition changes during a feed, and fat concentration increases with longer nursing sessions. The average composition of human milk and cows milk according to meigs early analyses, and those of certain wellknotisn authors whose results were available in 1881. The fat and lactose, respectively, provide 50% and 40% of the total energy of the milk 11. In comparison, a cow can produce a large volume of milk than a human mother. The quality of the feed is known to change the fat composition, the flavor and the quantity of the milk produced. The primary advantage nutritionally comes from the nature of the fat in the milk. When mothers take estrogen supplements, there is a very small. And, several videos include discussions of the nature of differences in milk composition among mammalian species, including comparisons of cow milk with human milk. Composition of human breast milk human breast milk is a complex matrix with a general composition of 87% water, 3.
702 112 297 309 1484 1346 1315 437 1490 1329 828 30 1356 690 466 1122 989 933 1503 349 301 484 530 48 418 1285 1468 352 572 873